After testing each platforms extensively myself, I believe Printify is your best option total. It provides entry to extra distinctive merchandise (like customized espresso), superior AI-powered design instruments, and an enormous vary of integration choices.
Prodigi does have its advantages although, from it’s simple to make use of interface, to its reasonably priced pricing, and eco-friendly method to manufacturing.
So, how do you make the correct selection? This whole comparability information will inform you the whole lot you should know.
The Fast Verdict
Printify beat Prodigi in a lot of the assessments I carried out. It has stronger design instruments (together with an AI image generator), extra distinctive product choices, extra printing choices, and offers you entry to a wider vary of gross sales channels.
There’s even a free pop-up retailer instrument.
Prodigi does excel in some areas, although. It provides entry to very cost-effective merchandise, is extraordinarily simple to make use of, and makes a speciality of sustainable print on demand.
Prodigi Execs and Cons
Execs:
- Sturdy dedication to sustainable manufacturing and achievement
- Over 500,000 customizable merchandise
- Simple-to-use interface (very best for learners)
- Quick manufacturing instances (24-48 hours for many merchandise)
- Simple mockup generator
Cons:
- The design instruments are comparatively fundamental
- No premium plans with additional perks
- Fewer gross sales channels
Printify Execs and Cons
Execs:
- Numerous distinctive merchandise, together with magnificence gadgets and occasional
- Integrations with dozens of gross sales channels
- Enormous vary of world producers
- Nice AI-powered design instruments
- Numerous branding and customization choices
- Free pop-up retailer creator
Cons:
- Product pricing and high quality can differ
- Some producers have slower manufacturing instances
Prodigi vs Printify: Core Options
On the floor, Prodigi and Printify appear fairly comparable. They each offer you instantaneous entry to a whole bunch of customizable merchandise, design instruments, mockup mills, and international achievement providers.
Additionally they each combine with ecommerce platforms and marketplaces (although Printify has extra choices to select from).
Nevertheless, I seen some key variations when testing these platforms myself.
Product Selection and High quality
Let’s begin with one of the vital necessary components to contemplate when selecting a POD platform – the merchandise.
Prodigi appears to supply extra customizable products than Printify, telling corporations they will add designs to over 500,000 totally different gadgets. However there aren’t many distinctive choices to select from.
Printify offers you greater than 900 merchandise to customise, together with choices you received’t discover wherever else, like branded espresso and cosmetics.
Prodigi additionally doesn’t appear to have as many superior printing choices, like all-over-print and sublimation – whereas Printify does.
One different level to notice is that Prodigi makes a speciality of sustainable and eco-friendly printing and manufacturing.
They supply sustainable supplies, and work with native distribution corporations to reduce your carbon footprint.
Nevertheless, the identical may very well be stated for Printify. Additionally they offer sustainable merchandise, and work with suppliers worldwide.
From a product high quality perspective, each corporations have their professionals and cons. They each comply with strict high quality assurance measures and use cutting-edge expertise, alongside prime quality supplies.
Nevertheless, Prodigi has earned a couple of unfavourable opinions for its printing readability previously.
Printify, however, does have a fairly good fame, however for the reason that company outsources printing to a whole bunch of various international producers, it’s tough to know precisely what you’re going to get.
I’d undoubtedly advocate studying the opinions for every Printify vendor, and ordering samples earlier than you select your provider.
Design and Customization Choices
As I discussed above, Printify appears to supply extra methods to customise your merchandise, with issues like “all-over-print”.
Additionally they offer you extra methods to showcase your model on the gadgets you create, with customized tags, packing slips, and different components. I couldn’t discover many branding choices on Prodigi.
In relation to the design expertise, there’s little doubt that Printify is the superior platform. Whereas I do like how handy and simple Prodigi’s design instruments and mockup generator are, Printify is basically on the reducing fringe of the POD market.
It provides entry to AI-powered picture mills, that may create distinctive graphics for you based mostly on prompts.
Plus, you get entry to an enormous vary of free resources and belongings you possibly can add to your designs. Printify’s mockup generator is implausible too, permitting you to create photographs of your merchandise in “life-style” settings, in order that they actually stand out in your web site.
Plus, should you need assistance with design, Printify provides a spread of providers, together with their “Consultants Program”, to assist match you to designers and different specialists.
Integrations and Gross sales Channels
Printify wins once more from a gross sales channel and scalability perspective – arms down. Prodigi does combine with among the prime platforms, like Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce, and Etsy.
Nevertheless, Printify integrates with much more channels. You possibly can join the platform to your Walmart or Ebay storefront, TikTok Store, and PrestaShop.
Printify also allows you to sell directly by way of their platform with out utilizing an integration. You possibly can create a Printify pop-up store without spending a dime, and share a custom-made hyperlink along with your buyers.
Although this “pop-up retailer” is fairly fundamental, it’s an effective way to begin promoting without spending a dime, with out having to handle the entire complications of constructing and managing your personal web site.
In fact, in case you are utilizing the pop-up retailer service, I’d undoubtedly advocate branching out to a couple further gross sales channels as quickly as doable. That’ll assist you to construct a extra memorable model, and enhance your possibilities of elevated gross sales.
Ease of Use and Buyer Help
In my view, there’s not an enormous quantity of distinction between Printify and Prodigi in the case of ease of use.
Each platforms are extraordinarily easy and designed for learners. You’ll don’t have any drawback signing up for an account and creating designs.
Printify is a little more intuitive, with its versatile dashboard for monitoring orders, AI capabilities in its design instruments, and it’s step-by-step instrument suggestions.
Nevertheless, since you are able to do much more with Printify than Prodigi, you would possibly spend somewhat longer studying how the whole lot works.
From a buyer help perspective, each corporations supply entry to tons of self-help sources like movies, blogs, and tutorials.
I do assume Printify’s weblog web page is much more spectacular, although. Printify additionally provides direct buyer help by way of chat and e-mail.
The one draw back is that the producers you’re employed with by way of the platform don’t at all times reply shortly to questions.
Prodigi provides buyer help primarily by way of e-mail, and from what I can inform, you may need to attend somewhat longer to get a response, notably throughout busy durations.
Prodigi vs Printify: Pricing and Charges
Now, let’s take a look at pricing. First, by way of product charges, Printify and Prodigi are fairly comparable. Each supply entry to a spread of reasonably priced gadgets, though the pricing can differ on Printify relying on the producer you select.
Each corporations additionally permit customers to get began without spending a dime. There aren’t any limitations on the free plans, and you may create as many merchandise as you want.
Nevertheless, Printify does supply some “premium” plan choices, that are worthwhile, in my view, for scaling corporations.
The Premium plan for $24.99 per thirty days (paid yearly), lets you create as much as 10 shops, and offers you as much as 20% reductions on all merchandise – which significantly boosts your revenue margins.
Plus, there’s an Enterprise plan with greater reductions for the most important corporations. You can even pay for additional providers from Printify, like internet design help, and categorical supply.
I truthfully assume the premium plans give Printify an edge over Prodigi, as they will prevent some huge cash as you begin to promote extra merchandise.
Prodigi vs Printify: The Verdict
Merely put, Printify outperforms Prodigi in just about each space.
Whereas Prodigi does supply some nice eco-friendly choices for sustainable corporations, and entry to a variety of merchandise, it may’t compete with Printify’s superb design instruments, or distinctive product choices.
Printify additionally offers you extra alternatives to promote by way of numerous channels (together with your personal free pop-up store). Plus, it’s premium plans can help you to save money as your business scales.
